How contingency fees work for car accident lawyers A percentage of the recovery, or nothing.
A contingency fee means no attorney fee unless there is a recovery. Business and Professions Code section 6147 sets what your agreement has to say, California caps the percentage only in medical malpractice, and the fee, costs, and liens come out of your check in order.
On this page
A contingency fee means the lawyer is paid a percentage of what you recover and nothing if you recover nothing. In California that percentage is set by your written agreement rather than by law. Business and Professions Code section 6147 requires the agreement to state the rate, explain how costs affect both the fee and your recovery, and tell you in writing that the fee is negotiable.
What a contingency fee is
An hourly lawyer bills for time and gets paid whether the case wins or loses. A contingency lawyer is paid a share of the recovery, which means the fee arrives only if money does. The risk moves from the client, who usually cannot fund a case against an insurance company, to the firm, which can.
A firm therefore has to be selective, because every case it takes is a case it is funding. If a lawyer turns your case down, that is information about the economics, not necessarily about the merits.
What your fee agreement must say
This is the part that protects you. Section 6147 requires that a contingency fee agreement be in writing, signed by both the attorney and the client, with a duplicate copy given to the client at the time it is signed. It must include the following.
Read your agreement against that list before you sign it. California attorneys are also bound by rule 1.5 of the Rules of Professional Conduct, which prohibits an unconscionable or illegal fee, and by rule 1.15, which governs how client money is held in trust. You can verify any lawyer’s license and discipline history through the State Bar of California.
California caps fees only in malpractice
In a car accident case there is no statutory ceiling on a contingency fee, which is why section 6147 requires the agreement to tell you the fee is negotiable. Any article that tells you California caps injury fees is describing a rule that does not exist.
One category is capped. Section 6146 limits contingency fees in claims against a health care provider for professional negligence to twenty-five percent of a recovery obtained by settlement and release before a civil complaint or arbitration demand is filed, and thirty-three percent of a recovery obtained after one is filed. If the case is tried or arbitrated, the attorney may ask the court or arbitrator to approve more on a showing of good cause. The statute measures the recovery net of costs, and it applies to medical malpractice and to nothing else.
What is common in practice is a tiered rate: one percentage if the case resolves before a lawsuit is filed, a higher one after. The trigger is defined in your agreement, not by statute, and the triggers vary: filing the complaint, a set number of days before trial, or an appeal. Ask which event moves your rate and get the answer in the document rather than in the meeting.
The order money comes out
A settlement check does not go to you first. It goes into the firm’s client trust account, and four things come out in order: the attorney fee, the case costs, the medical liens and outstanding balances, and then you. Case costs are the money spent to build the case, which is different from the fee: filing fees, deposition transcripts, medical record charges, expert witness fees, service of process, and postage.
Whether the fee is calculated on the gross recovery or after costs are deducted changes what you take home, and the table below runs one settlement both ways.
| Line | Fee on the gross recovery | Fee after costs are deducted |
|---|---|---|
| Settlement | $100,000 | $100,000 |
| Case costs | $5,000 | $5,000 |
| Attorney fee at one third | $33,333 | $31,667 |
| Medical liens and balances | $15,000 | $15,000 |
| To you | $46,667 | $48,333 |
Same settlement, same percentage, $1,666 of difference from one line in a contract. That is the question to ask before you sign.
Who gets to reduce the liens
A lien is a legal claim on your recovery held by someone who paid for your treatment. It is the line that surprises people, because it is often larger than the difference between one fee percentage and another.
| Who is claiming | What they can recover | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Your health plan or disability insurer | Capped at one third of the money due to you if you have a lawyer, one half if you do not, reduced pro rata for attorney fees and costs and by any comparative fault percentage | Civil Code 3040 |
| A hospital that treated you after the crash | A lien for the reasonable value of the emergency and ongoing services, if the hospital perfected the lien correctly, meaning took the formal steps the statute requires | Civil Code 3045.1 |
| Medi-Cal | The reasonable value of the benefits it paid on your behalf | Welfare and Institutions Code 14124.72 |
| Medicare | Conditional payments it made for treatment related to the crash | Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services |
| A workers compensation insurer, if you were working | The compensation and benefits it paid, by lien or by its own claim against the at-fault driver | Labor Code 3852 |
Civil Code section 3040 caps a health plan lien at one third of the money due to you when you have engaged an attorney, and one half when you have not. Subdivisions (e) and (f) reduce it further by any comparative fault percentage and pro rata, meaning in proportion, for your attorney fees and costs under the common fund doctrine, the rule that whoever benefits from the recovery shares the cost of getting it. Civil Code section 3045.1 creates the hospital lien. Welfare and Institutions Code section 14124.72 covers Medi-Cal recovery, Labor Code section 3852 covers the workers compensation lien, and Medicare conditional payments are handled through the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.
Why liens matter more than the fee
Clients negotiate the fee percentage. The larger number is usually on the lien line, and it is negotiable in a way the statute anticipates. A health plan lien of $40,000 reduced to $18,000 puts $22,000 in the client’s pocket, which is more than moving a fee from forty percent to thirty-three percent on a $100,000 case.
That is the reason to ask a firm how it handles liens as well as what it charges. A higher gross settlement with an unreduced lien can leave a client with less than a smaller settlement handled carefully at the end. The last thirty days of a case decide more of the client’s net than most of the months before it.
When a contingency fee does not fit
Not every claim needs a lawyer, and we would rather say so than take a case that does not need us. If nobody was injured, liability is clear, and the dispute is only about the cost of a repair, a contingency fee can cost more than the argument is worth. California small claims court hears cases up to a set dollar limit without lawyers, and the Judicial Council small claims self-help guide explains the process and the current limits.
The calculation changes as soon as there is an injury. Once medical treatment, wage loss, liens, and policy limits are in play, the file gets complicated in ways that reward the person who deals with insurers every day, and the fee comes out of a recovery that would usually have been smaller without it.
How our fee works
We take car accident cases on a contingency fee. The fee comes out of the recovery, and there is no fee unless we recover. Our agreement answers each of the questions above in writing before you sign, as section 6147 requires, and we walk through what comes out of a settlement, in what order, on the first call rather than after the check arrives. Our car accident lawyer fees page carries the full breakdown, and the case results page shows what several of our files recovered. Ask, and keep asking until the answer is plain.
Questions people ask about contingency fees
Do I owe anything if we lose?
Is the percentage really negotiable?
Why does the fee go up if a lawsuit is filed?
Do contingency fees apply to my car repair?
Can I switch lawyers in the middle of a case?
Does the fee come out before or after my medical bills are paid?
Does a verbal fee agreement count?
How contingency fees work
You pay a percentage of what is recovered and nothing if nothing is recovered. In California the percentage lives in a written agreement that has to state the rate, explain how costs affect the fee and your recovery, and tell you the fee is negotiable. There is no statutory cap outside medical malpractice, and the number that decides your net is the percentage, the costs, and the liens, in that order.
Before you sign anything, ask whether the fee is calculated before or after costs, what happens to costs if there is no recovery, and how the firm handles lien reduction. If you want us to look at the agreement in front of you, or at the crash behind it, tell us what happened. There is no fee unless we recover.
